``They thought their attorneys had found the magic agreement to get
around U.S. laws, Marshall told The Herald in a telephone interview from
Havana. ``They knew full well I was here. Now they've had some sort of
memory loss.
The dispute casts a spotlight on efforts by foreign businessmen to
quietly establish footholds for profitable U.S. goods and services in Cuba
in hopes the U.S. embargo will be lifted sooner rather than later.
Although Marshall has maintained an Internet page offering
apartments in Cuba for 18 months, RE/MAX officials in Colorado said they
became aware of it only earlier this year.
``The purchase of real estate in Cuba is now a reality!'' the page
trumpets. ``Condos, homes, office space and more. Probably the most
anxiously awaited real estate opportunity in the Americas.
The page makes no mention of the U.S. embargo, but notes that all
the apartments for sale are in new buildings, not properties seized by the
government from Cuban or U.S. citizens.
``RE/MAX International has emphatically not authorized anyone to
operate in Cuba, Daryl Jesperson, president of the Denver-based firm, told
The Herald.
RE/MAX lawyers are investigating the ``illegal use of the firm's name
in Cuba and informing U.S. authorities, added Jesperson, whose firm has
3,200 independently owned and operated franchises in 30 countries.
Marshall has certainly not tried to hide his work in Cuba. Spain's El
Pais newspaper, Cuba's Foreign Trade magazine and The Financial Times in
London reported on his real estate deals in 1997 and 1998.
The Financial Times quoted him as saying he had established a joint
venture with a Cuban government agency to market a half-dozen apartment
buildings being built in Havana by Spanish and Monacan investors.
U.S. advocates of increasing business with Cuba swiftly pointed to
RE/MAX Havana to prove that U.S. firms could carry out legal deals in
Cuba. The Herald recently ran a story listing RE/MAX among several
American firms with foreign partners that were doing business in Cuba.
But the burgeoning publicity prompted Jesperson to issue an angry
statement May 19 saying he was ``incensed that someone has had that
audacity to blatantly and illegally utilize the RE/MAX name in Cuba.
Jesperson said he had begun hearing vague rumors last year that someone
was using the RE/MAX name in Cuba, but managed to confirm RE/MAX Havana's
existence only recently, after seeing Marshall's Web page (www.realestatecuba.com).
Jesperson said Marshall is the RE/MAX franchise holder only in the
British-run Turks and Caicos Islands, not in Cuba. He also said his
Caribbean subfranchiser, Patrick Murphy, who is based in Puerto Rico,
could not have sold a Cuba franchise because that would violate the U.S.
embargo.
Murphy declined to comment on whether he had sold the Cuba franchise to
Marshall. ``I will gladly comment once I find out more about what's been
written and what has happened, he told The Herald in a brief telephone
interview.
But Marshall said he bought the Cuba franchise from Murphy with the
full knowledge and approval of the Colorado office, based on opinions from
RE/MAX lawyers that the deal would not violate U.S. laws.
Marshall said Murphy attended his office opening in Havana last
October, and had earlier signed him up for a training course in Colorado
during which he discussed Cuba business prospects with company
officials.
His Web page features a photograph of him meeting with a senior RE/MAX
official in Colorado last July.
Ironically, experts on the U.S. embargo say there may be nothing
illegal in the deal.
Marshall is a British citizen not subject to U.S. laws such as the
embargo, they said, and his alleged deal with Murphy, for a flat fee with
no future royalties or profit sharing required, may allow Murphy to claim
he has done no business in or with Cuba.
At worst, Marshall may be infringing on the RE/MAX trademark, the
experts added. Jesperson said RE/MAX International never registered its
trademark in Cuba, and Marshall said he registered it for local use
only.
``If RE/MAX Havana registered the name there, you'd have to go into a
very technical and tough legal battle to force it to stop using the name,
said one U.S. lawyer experienced in Cuba trademark issues.
The battle would be all the tougher, the lawyer added, because Cuba's
government is incensed over a U.S. federal court's recent refusal to
protect the trademark of the Cuban-made Havana Club rum in a case against
the Bacardi rum giant.
``Cuba has little incentive to protect the trademark rights of the
RE/MAX in Colorado when a U.S. court has refused to protect the trademark
of a Cuban firm, the lawyer said.
U.S. Realtor denies Cuban connection
RE/MAX chief: Havana firm using logo
illegally
But it wasn't until Marshall's Web page began getting notice early this
year that the dispute erupted, largely because the page was perceived as
evidence that the Colorado firm had found a way to work legally in
Cuba.
e-mail: jtamayo@herald.com