LETTERS
TO THE EDITOR
August 16,
2000
Upon
hearing that Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) Commissioner
Doris M. Meissner was holding an awards ceremony for the INS agents
involved in the April 22 raid on the home of Elian Gonzalez's Miami
relatives, I remembered the prophetic words of George Orwell. "Who
controls the past controls the future: who controls the present controls
the past." The Clinton administration is attempting to rewrite a
shameful chapter of American history with this awards ceremony
("Snatching Elian has its
reward," Aug. 10).
Laurence H. Tribe,
professor of constitutional law at Harvard University, described the raid
as having "violated a basic principle of our society, a principle
whose preservation lies at the core of ordered liberty under the rule of
law."
According to Mr. Tribe, under
the Constitution, the executive branch has no unilateral authority to
forcibly enter people's homes to remove innocent persons. Mr. Tribe
has said that the agents who stormed the home of Elian's great-uncle,
Lazaro Gonzalez, did not have a warrant to seize the child, but only to
search the home.
A second constitutional
lawyer and expert on civil liberties, Alan Dershowitz, denounced the raid
as an illegal operation, stating that the raid created the "terrible
precedent that the administration can act without court approval and break
into the home of an American citizen. It's a dangerous day for all
Americans."
Shame on the Clinton
administration for ordering civil servants to carry out illegal actions
that do violence to our Constitution and our way of life. Shame on those
men and women who followed illegal orders rather than the law they are
sworn to uphold. It was not only the home of the Gonzalez family that was
attacked on April 22, but also our Constitution. Let us use these awards
of shame to remember, speak the truth and defend our fundamental
freedoms.
JOHN
SUAREZ
Miami