Effective civil disobedience should be directed at the oppressing
institution, not bystanders.
Miami's Cuban exile community has done neither -- and now finds itself
increasingly isolated on the issue and drawing growing hostility.
Protest leaders seem clueless about a reality that's obvious to
everyone else: You don't convert others to your cause by annoying them.
The exiles did draw attention to their cause by blocking traffic and
defying police, leading to the arrest of more than 130. The tactics
generated news coverage around the world.
But it generated no sympathy for the exile cause. That's because there
is nothing heroic about civil disobedience aimed at uninvolved parties.
Rosa Parks defied segregationist authorities when she refused to
surrender her seat on a bus to a white man. Black civil rights
demonstrators refused to leave the very lunch counters where they were
denied service. Vietnam War protesters handcuffed themselves to the gates
of the White House. Environmentalists take up positions in front of
bulldozers.
What sense did it make for the exiles to make Miami motorists the
targets of their civil disobedience? They aren't responsible for Fidel
Castro's government, Juan Miguel Gonzalez's demand that his son be
returned to him in Cuba nor the decision by the U.S. Immigration and
Naturalization Service to comply.
Raising a person's ire isn't the same as raising that individual's
consciousness.
Also, the Cuban community's inability -- or lack of desire -- to build
bridges of understanding and respect with non-Cubans has come back to
haunt it with regard to Elian.
Since emerging as a significant presence here, Cubans have not
particularly needed allies. They've prospered, placing their cultural and
political stamp on Miami-Dade County largely by using their own resources
and determination.
In addition, many have set the bar of friendship too high for most
non-Cubans to reach.
For many Cubans, especially older ones, the day begins and ends with
hatred for Castro. Few non-Cubans can match that level of passion
regarding Cuba, nor are they likely to hold the same priority.
The result: many older Cubans view non-Cubans as irrelevant to their
lives, if not as obstacles to the mission of deposing Castro.
None of that prevented them from gaining considerable power within
Miami-Dade, and disproportionate influence in Washington. On Friday,
U.S. Rep. Dan Burton, R-Ind., acquiesced to exile wishes and subpoenaed
Elian, a move designed to prevent his immediate deportation.
But inevitably, there comes a day when any community needs support from
outside -- from ethnic and cultural communities that don't share its
history and passions.
Elian Gonzalez's future is such an issue.
Cuban Miami has not been able to control Elian's fate by sheer
will. The community is too small on a national scale. Also, the number of
non-Cubans who have strong feelings about Castro pales against the number
who value family unity -- and thus are arrayed against those exiles who
believe Castro is a good reason to keep Elian from his father.
In this instance, Cuban Americans need much broader public support and
sympathy to make their case.
But the support isn't there. And this week's disruptions have all but
guaranteed that it isn't forthcoming.
Rather than seeing a Cuban community bravely standing up for a noble
cause, most observers instead see bitter people lashing out at innocents
because they haven't gotten their way.Cuban exiles in need of allies
by Robert Steinback