|
Chapter
4
|
Menu
and Nutrition Requirements
|
A.
Background
- Nutritional
Needs of Older Adults
- National Evaluation of Nutrition Program Meals
B.
Nutrient Recommendations
- Federal Nutrition Policy
- Dietary Reference Intakes (DRIs)
- Dietary Guidelines
- Older American Act
- Issue Panel and Recommendations
- Nutrient Values for Menu Planning and Evaluation
C. Menu Planning
- Menu Planning Process
- Nutrient Analysis Software
- Meal Patterns
- Updated Sample Meal Pattern
- Suggested Food Group Components and Serving Size
- Enhancing the Nutritional Quality of the Meal: Key Nutrients
- Sources of Key Nutrients
- Nutrition Labeling / Daily Values
D.
Special Dietary Needs
- Sample SUA Modified and Therapeutic Diet Standards
- Nutrition Supplements
- Sample SUA Use of Nutrition Supplements Standards
- Texture Modified Meals
- Ethnic and Religious Meals
E.
Menu Review and Approval
- Sample SUA Menu Approval Standards
- Menu Substitutions
F.
Meal Service Options
- Multiple Meals
- Weekend Meals
- Frozen Meals
- Menu Choice
- Shelf-stable / Emergency Meals
-
Supplements Definitions
-
Additional Resources
-
References
|
INTRODUCTION
Planning nutritious, appetizing, economical meals is a complex, multifaceted
task. Menu planning plays a critical role in the delivery of quality
services in Older Americans Nutrition Programs (OANPs). There are
many factors to take into consideration in developing menus. The elements
of menu planning noted below include suggested Best Practices.
A.
BACKGROUND
|
Nutritional Needs of Older Adults |
Scientific
evidence increasingly supports the positive role nutrition plays
in good health, self-sufficiency, and quality of life of older adults.
Many older adults undergo changes in their lives (eg, physiological,
social, family, environmental, economic), which may affect their
dietary intake. Nutrition-related risk factors include hunger, food
security, poverty, inadequate food and nutrient intake, social isolation,
depression, dementia, dependency, functional disability, chewing
and swallowing difficulties, presence of diet-related acute or chronic
diseases or conditions, polypharmacy, minority status, urban and
rural geographic areas, advanced age, and living alone. If ignored,
these risk factors could weaken nutritional status, increase medical
complications, and result in loss of independence (1,2).
Malnutrition
and dehydration are associated with delayed healing, altered immune
response and increased risk of infections, increased severity of
coexisting diseases, altered drug metabolism, decreased muscle strength,
and behavioral symptoms such as confusion, apathy, depression, and
memory loss. For the homebound, lack of transportation, weak family
and social networks, physical barriers, and inadequate funds for
food also contribute to inadequate nutrition (3). Physiologic function
gradually declines with age and may result in decreased taste, smell,
and appetite. In addition, polypharmacy, functional impairment,
and multiple medical and social problems all place older persons
at higher risk than the general population. Malnutrition leads to
increased difficulty with activities of daily living and decreased
quality of life (4).
The
need for and the success of the OANPs is based on the scientific
evidence that indicates that adequate nutrition is necessary to
maintain cognitive and physical functioning, to prevent, reduce,
and manage chronic disease and disease-related disabilities, and
to sustain health and a good quality of life (5,6). Millions of
older adults lack access to adequate amounts and quality of food
necessary to sustain health and decrease the risk of disability.
The provision of meals helps older adults maintain their health
(7) as well as minimize their out-of-pocket food expenses so they
can purchase other necessities such as medications, utilities, and
shelter. The OANP provides an opportunity to implement interventions
to address obesity, multiple chronic diseases such as diabetes,
heart disease, stroke, hypertension, osteoporosis, osteoarthritis,
cancer, and hypercholesterolemia through healthy meals, nutrition
education and counseling and linkages to physical activity and wellness
programs.
|
|
|
| National
Evaluation of Nutrition Program Meals |
The National
Evaluation of the Older Americans Nutrition Program 1993-95 (8)
found that the average OANP meal provided more than 50% of the 1989 Recommended
Dietary Allowances (RDAs) for many nutrients based on adult male values.
The National Evaluation concluded that both congregate and home-delivered
meals contributed significantly to participants' daily nutrient intake,
and therefore, their nutritional status. When
comparing the nutrient content of OANP meals at the time of the National
Evaluation to newer Dietary Reference Intakes (DRIs) (including RDA
and other values described below), the meals would have been deficient
in vitamins D, E, folate, and magnesium. Other nutrients met or exceeded
the newer DRI/RDA values. See Table
2 Nutrient Availability of an Older Americans Nutrition Program Meal Relative
to the Dietary Reference Intakes and Recommended Dietary Allowances
compiled by the National Policy and Resource Center on Nutrition and Aging
(Center).
The use of
the newer DRI/RDA values to plan and evaluate OANP meals was addressed
by an Issue Panel convened by the Center in February 2002 (reviewed later
in this chapter). Recommendations from this and future Issue Panels will
continue to shape OANP practice and guidelines.
B.
NUTRITION RECOMMENDATIONS
Congress
reauthorized the Older Americans Act (OAA) in 2000 for 5 years. OAA Section
339 requires that nutrition projects meet the Dietary Guidelines for
Americans (9), published by the Secretaries of Health and Human Services
and Agriculture and the RDAs (which are now included in the DRIs) established
by the Food and Nutrition Board, Institute of Medicine of the National
Academy of Sciences. The National Nutrition Monitoring and Related Research
Act of 1990 (Public Law 101-445) requires that the Secretaries of Health
and Human Services and Agriculture contract with a scientific body, such
as the National Academy of Sciences, to publish reports on nutrient requirements
and status of the United States on a 2 to 5 year basis and to develop
Dietary Guidelines every 5 years. The Act requires that all federal
food, nutrition, and health programs promote the Dietary Guidelines. Thus,
the most recent versions of the DRIs and Dietary Guidelines serve
as the cornerstone for federal nutrition policy.
| Dietary
Reference Intakes |
The new DRIs
(10-15) provide values for men and women aged 51-70 and over 70 years.
The DRI values include an RDA or an Adequate Intake for nutrients with
no established RDA, and a Tolerable Upper Intake Level. Refer to Table
1 Dietary Reference Intakes for Older Adults compiled by the Center
for current nutrient values established by the Food and Nutrition Board.
- The RDA
is the average daily dietary intake level that is sufficient to meet
the nutrient requirement for nearly all (97-98%) healthy individuals
of a specified age range and gender.
- The Adequate
Intake (AI) is the daily dietary intake level of healthy people
assumed to be adequate when there is insufficient evidence to set an
RDA. It is based on observed mean nutrient intakes and experimental
data. The National Academy of Sciences recommends that the Adequate
Intake be used if an RDA is not available.
- The Tolerable
Upper Intake Level (UL) is the highest daily dietary intake that
is likely to pose no risk of adverse health effects to almost all individuals
of a specific age range.
- The
Estimated Energy Requirement (EER) is defined as the dietary energy
intake that is predicted (with variance) to maintain energy balance
in a healthy adult of defined age, gender, weight, height and level
of activity, consistent with good health.
- An Acceptable
Macronutrient Distribution Range (AMDR) is defined as a range of
intakes for a particular energy source (ie, carbohydrates, proteins,
fats) that is associated with reduced risk of chronic disease while
providing adequate intakes of essential nutrients. The AMDR is expressed
as a percentage of total energy intake because its requirement is not
independent of other energy fuel sources or of the total energy requirement
of the individual.
The newer
DRIs include RDAs for older adults that are higher than the 1989 RDAs
for vitamins B-12, C, D, E, K, folate, calcium, and magnesium. The DRIs
provide equations to calculate an individual's energy requirements based
on activity level (the EER). To meet the body's daily nutritional needs
while minimizing risk for chronic disease, an AMDR was established for
carbohydrate to be 45-65% of total calories, for fat, 20-35% of total
calories, and for protein, 10-35% of total calories. The DRIs also suggests
that no more than 25% of total calories come from added sugars (those
incorporated into foods and beverages during production and processing).
The DRIs now emphasize the importance of physical activity and recommends
that adults strive for an "active" lifestyle that is equivalent
to 60 minutes of moderately intense physical activity throughout each
day (15).
| Dietary
Guidelines for Americans |
The 2000
Dietary Guidelines for Americans (5th ed.) are the most current
guidelines to be followed when planning and serving OANP meals. These
guidelines are incorporated in the selection of foods and serving sizes
for meals as well as the basis for nutrition guidance for individuals
and groups. The 3 main themes are:
1.
Aim
for Fitness
- Aim
for a healthy weight. Choose a lifestyle that combines sensible eating
with regular physical activity. To be at their best, adults need to
avoid gaining weight, and many need to lose weight. Being overweight
or obese increases your risk for high blood pressure, high blood cholesterol,
heart disease, stroke, diabetes, certain types of cancer, arthritis,
and breathing problems. A healthy weight is key to a long, healthy
life.
Be physically
active each day (a new recommendation). Being physically active and
maintaining a healthy weight are both needed for good health, but
they benefit health in different ways. Children, teens, adults, and
the elderlyall can improve their health and well-being and have
fun by including moderate amounts of physical activity in their daily
lives.
2.
Build a Healthy Base
- Let
the pyramid guide your choices. Different foods contain different
nutrients and other healthful substances. No single food can supply
all the nutrients in the amounts you need. For example, oranges provide
vitamin C and folate but no vitamin B12; cheese provides calcium and
vitamin B12; but no vitamin C. Choose the recommended number of daily
servings from each of the five major food groups. If you avoid all
foods from any of the five food groups, seek guidance to help ensure
that you get all the nutrients you need.
- Choose
a variety of grains, especially whole grains. They provide vitamins,
minerals, carbohydrates (starch and dietary fiber), and other substances
that are important for good health. Whole grains differ from refined
grains in the amount of fiber and nutrients they provide, and different
whole grain foods differ in nutrient content, so choose a variety
of whole and enriched grains. Eating plenty of whole grains may help
protect you against many chronic diseases.
- Choose
a variety of fruits and vegetables daily. Eating plenty of fruits
and vegetables of different kinds may help protect you against many
chronic diseases. It also promotes healthy bowel function. Fruits
and vegetables provide essential vitamins and minerals, fiber, and
other substances that are important for good health. To promote your
health, eat a variety of fruits and vegetablesat least 2 servings
of fruits and 3 servings of vegetableseach day.
- Keep
food safe to eat (a new recommendation). Foods that are safe from
harmful bacteria, viruses, parasites, and chemical contaminants are
vital for healthful eating. Safe means that the food poses little
risk of foodborne illness. Farmers, food producers, markets, food
service establishments, and other food preparers have a role to keep
food as safe as possible. However, we also need to keep and prepare
foods safely in the home, and be alert when eating out.
3.
Choose Sensibly
- Choose
a diet that is low in saturated fat and cholesterol and moderate in
total fat. Fats supply energy and essential fatty acids, and they
help absorb the fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K, and carotenoids.
Some kinds of fat, especially saturated fats, increase the risk for
coronary heart disease by raising the blood cholesterol. In contrast,
unsaturated fats (found mainly in vegetable oils) do not increase
blood cholesterol. Eating lots of fat of any type can provide excess
calories.
- Choose
beverages and foods to moderate your intake of sugars. Sugars are
carbohydrates and a source of energy (calories). Dietary carbohydrates
also include the complex carbohydrates starch and dietary fiber. Sugars
and starches occur naturally in many foods that also supply other
nutrients.
- Choose
and prepare foods with less salt. Many people can reduce their chances
of developing high blood pressure by consuming less salt. Many studies
in diverse populations have shown that a high sodium intake is associated
with higher blood pressure. At present, the firmest link between salt
intake and health relates to blood pressure. High salt intake also
increases the amount of calcium excreted in the urine. Eating less
salt may decrease the loss of calcium from bone. Loss of too much
calcium from bone increases the risk of osteoporosis and bone fractures.
- If you
drink alcoholic beverages, do so in moderation. Alcoholic
beverages supply calories but few nutrients. Current evidence suggests
that moderate drinking is associated with a lower risk for coronary
heart disease in some individuals. However, higher levels of alcohol
intake raise the risk for high blood pressure, stroke, heart disease,
certain cancers, accidents, violence, suicides, birth defects, and
overall mortality (deaths). Older adults have a decreased ability
to metabolize alcohol due to physiological changes and as a result
may be at greater risk of adverse consequences.
| Older
Americans Act 2000 Nutrition Requirements |
SECTION
339 Nutrition
A State that establishes and operates a nutrition project under this chapter
shall
(1) solicit the advise of a dietitian or individual with comparable expertise
in the planning of nutritional services, and
(2) ensure that the project --
(A) provides meals that --
(i) comply with the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, published by the
Secretary and the Secretary of Agriculture,
(ii) provide to each participating older individual
(I) a minimum of 33 1/3 percent of the daily recommended dietary allowances
as established by the Food and Nutrition Board of the Institute of Medicine
of the National Academy of Sciences, if the project provides one (1) meal
per day,
(ll) a minimum of 66 2/3 percent of the allowances if the project provides
two (2) meals per day, and
(III) 100 percent of the allowances if the project provides three (3)
meals per day, and
(iii) to the maximum extent practicable, are adjusted to meet any special
dietary needs of program participants.
(B) provides flexibility to local nutrition projects in designing meals
that are appealing to program participants,
| Issue
Panel on Dietary Reference Intakes and Dietary Guidelines in Older
Americans Act Nutrition Programs |
The Center
convened an Issue Panel: Dietary Reference Intakes and Dietary Guidelines
in OANPs in February 2002. Panelists included nutrition and aging-related
researchers, individuals involved in policy development, persons working
at the federal, state, and local program level, and representatives from
food industries. The Issue
Panel Report includes a summary, backgrounder and working documents,
and a directory of Issue Panelists (16).
The Issue
Panel focused on the rationale for and the use of the most recent DRIs
and Dietary Guidelines in the provision of OAA nutrition services,
including nutrition education, nutrition counseling, and congregate and
home-delivered meals. The Issue Panel Report was provided to the
US Administration on Aging for consideration. These recommendations will
assist in the development of guidance and technical assistance related
to implementation of the DRIs and Dietary Guidelines in the OANP.
State Units on Aging (SUAs), Area Agencies on Aging (AAAs), local service
providers, and Title VI grantees can use these recommendations in the
development of guidance and assistance for implementation. Recommendations
from the report are included in applicable sections of the Older Americans
Nutrition Program Toolkit.
The OAA states
that a project shall provide a meal that complies with the Dietary
Guidelines and a stated percentage of the RDAs which varies with the
number of meals served to a participant. Because it is the responsibility
of the SUA to implement the OAA, SUAs have incorporated these standards
into their policies and procedures.
| Issue
Panel Recommendations for Meeting Nutrition Requirements |
- OANP meals
should meet the current RDAs and AIs, and the 2000 Dietary Guidelines
for Americans, as these reflect the most recent scientific evidence
and provide the best-known guidance for meeting the nutrition needs
of older adults in America.
- OANPs
should strive to ensure that each meal is reasonably well-balanced nutritionally
and reflects the 2000 Dietary Guidelines since the meals provide
a positive nutrition education model for participants. To best serve
the nutrition and educational needs of participants, OANPs that serve
1 meal per day should ensure that each meal offers at least 33 1/3%
of the RDAs/Adequate Intakes. OANPs that serve two meals per day should
ensure that the sum of the two meals offers at least 66 2/3% of the
RDAs/Adequate Intakes (but each meal itself does not have to be 33 1/3%)
and those serving three meals per day should ensure that the sum of
these three meals offers 100% of the RDAs/Adequate Intakes.
- In addition
to providing meals that meet the 2000 Dietary Guidelines and
1/3 of the RDAs/Adequate Intakes, OANPs should emphasize foods high
in fiber, calcium, and protein. To the extent possible, programs should
continue to target vitamins A and C, with vitamin A provided from vegetable-derived
(carotenoid) sources. However, targeting specific nutrients such as
those mentioned in this recommendation should not be misinterpreted
as permission to ignore other nutrients. More specific recommendations
regarding targeting nutrients should be addressed at a future Issue
Panel.
- OANPs
should plan and evaluate meals for meeting the 2000 Dietary Guidelines
and 1/3 RDA/Adequate Intake standards by computer-assisted analysis.
Furthermore, Registered Dietitians (or individuals with comparable expertise)
should be available at the SUA, AAA, and local provider level to assure
nutrient adequacy of meals. If a meal pattern is used, it should be
based on the food servings delineated in the Food Guide Pyramid that
combined would meet 1/3 the RDAs/Adequate Intakes and the 2000 Dietary
Guidelines, be tested for meeting standards, and include increased
servings of fruits, vegetables, and whole grains.
- Assuming
culturally appropriate meals, OANPs should accommodate specific dietary
needs to the extent possible. To better serve defined groups and individuals
who require customization or therapeutic diets, OANPs would benefit
from the availability of Registered Dietitians (or individuals with
comparable expertise) -- who could also conduct needs assessments of
the populations their programs serve.
| Nutrient
Values for Meal Planning and Evaluation |
The table
below presents the most current DRIs and other nutrient values to use
when planning and evaluating meals. Values are provided for serving 1,
or a combination of 2 or 3 meals for 1 day's consumption for the average
older adult population served by the OANP. The nutrients selected include
those recommended for emphasis by the Issue Panel and those found in a
number of studies to be deficient or of concern in the diets of older
adults. (See "Enhancing the Nutritional Quality of the Meal"
section of this chapter). Refer to Table
1 Dietary Reference Intakes for Older Adults compiled by the Center
for all DRI values and footnotes.
|
Nutrient
Values for Meal Planning and Evaluation
|
| |
1
meal/day
33% RDA/AI
|
2
meals/day
67% RDA/AI
|
3
meals/day
100% RDA/AI
|
| Macronutrients |
|
| Kilocalories
(Kcal)(1) |
685
|
1369
|
2054
|
|
Protein
(gm)(2,3)
[20% of total Kcal (gm)] (4)
|
19
34
|
37
69
|
|
Carbohydrate
(gm) (5)
[50% of total Kcal (gm)] (4) |
43
86
|
87
171
|
130
257
|
Fat
(gm)
[30% of total Kcal (gm)] (6) |
23
|
46
|
68
|
Saturated
Fat
(<10% of total Kcal) (7) |
Limit
intake (8)
|
|
|
Cholesterol
(<300 gm/day) (7) |
Limit
intake (8)
|
|
|
| Dietary
Fiber (gm)(3) |
10*
|
20*
|
30*
|
| Vitamins |
|
Vitamin
A**(ug) (3)
|
300
|
600
|
900
|
| Vitamin
C (mg) (3) |
30
|
60
|
90
|
| Vitamin
D (ug) (3) |
5*
|
10*
|
15*
|
| Vitamin
E (mg) |
5
|
10
|
15
|
| Thiamin
(mg) (3) |
0.40
|
0.80
|
1.20
|
| Riboflavin
(mg) (3) |
0.43
|
0.86
|
1.30
|
| Vitamin
B6 (mg) (3) |
0.57
|
1.13
|
1.70
|
| Folate
(ug) |
133
|
267
|
400
|
| Vitamin
B12 (ug) |
0.79
|
1.61
|
2.4
|
| Minerals |
|
| Calcium
(mg) |
400*
|
800*
|
1200*
|
| Copper
(ug) |
300
|
600
|
900
|
| Iron
(mg) |
2.70
|
5.30
|
8.00
|
| Magnesium
(mg) (3) |
140
|
280
|
420
|
| Zinc
(mg) (3) |
3.70
|
7.30
|
11.00
|
| Electrolytes |
|
| Potassium
(mg) (9) |
1167
|
2333
|
3500
|
| Sodium
(mg) (7) |
<800
|
<1600
|
<2400
|
* RDAs are
in bold type and Adequate Intakes (AIs) are in ordinary type followed
by an asterisk (*).
**Vitamin
A should be provided from vegetable-derived (carotenoid) sources. See
Issue
Panel Report on Dietary Reference Intakes and Dietary Guidelines in Older
Americans Act Nutrition Programs.
(1) Value for 75 year old male, height of 5'7", " low active"
physical activity level (PAL). Using Table 5-22 Estimated Energy Requirements
(EER) for Men and Women 30 Years of Age, calculated the median BMI and
calorie level for men and subtracted 10 kcal/day (from 2504 kcal) for
each year of age above 30.
(2) The RDA for protein equilibrium in adults is a minimum of 0.8g protein/kg
body weight for reference body weight.
(3) Used highest DRI value for ages 51+ and male and female.
(4) Acceptable Macronutrient Distribution Ranges (AMDRs) for intakes of
carbohydrates, proteins, and fats are expressed as percent of total calories.
The AMDR for protein is 10-35%, carbohydrate is 45-65%, total fat is 20-35%.
(5) The RDA for carbohydrate is the minimum adequate to maintain brain
function in adults.
(6) Because the percent of energy that is consumed as fat can vary greatly
while still meeting daily energy needs, an AMDR is provided in the absence
of an AI, EAR, or RDA for adults.
(7) Recommendations from the Dietary Guidelines for Americans 2000.
(8) Saturated fats, trans fatty acids, and dietary cholesterol have
no known beneficial role in preventing chronic disease and are not required
at any level in the diet. The recommendation is to keep intake as low
as possible while consuming a nutritionally adequate diet, as many of
the foods containing these fats also provide valuable nutrients. Institute
of Medicine, Food and Nutrition Board. Dietary Reference Intakes for Energy,
Carbohydrates, Fiber, Fat, Fatty Acids, Cholesterol, Protein, and Amino
Acids. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 2002.
(9) National Research Council, Food and Nutrition Board. Recommended Dietary
Allowances. 10th ed. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 1989.
Issue Panelists
generally agreed that there might be circumstances when it is not always
necessary for a single meal to meet the 1/3 requirement for every nutrient
for which an RDA or Adequate Intake has been established. The idea of
averaging nutrients over a longer period of time, such as a few days,
or week was discussed. However, averaging was rejected overall by Panelists
for periods longer than 1 day for the following reasons:
- The OANP
meal can provide a good example of healthy food choices and balanced
eating for participants, as well as demonstrate to federal policy makers
the best that the OANPs offer;
- The availability
of water-soluble nutrients, such as vitamin C, in foods may be reduced
over long cooking or transporting times. Thus, participants may not
be consuming the level of these nutrients that is planned; and
- The needs
of congregate and home-delivered meal participants may not be equally
met. Individuals who receive home-delivered meals five days per week
may have better nutrient intakes over time than congregate participants
that do not receive meals daily. Data indicate that only 60% of congregate
participants attend a dining center 5 days a week. It is possible that
participants might come on days when the meal contains less than requirements
(16).
The Center
plans to hold another Issue Panel (2003) regarding implementation of the
DRIs. It is expected that the Panel will develop more specificity for
energy (calories), the percentage of carbohydrate, protein, and fat to
total calories, and key nutrients that should be included in computer-assisted
menu analyses. The Issue Panel recommendations will be included in future
modifications of the above table and other sections of this chapter.
C.
MENU PLANNING
In order
to ensure nutrient quality for the health of older Americans and to comply
with the requirements of the OAA, SUAs establish written standards and
guidelines detailing the specific requirements for menu planning and approval.
Planning menus that includes input from participants is a best practice.
Information may be obtained through focus groups, advisory councils, suggestion
boxes, or surveys. Suggestions may also come from food production staff,
site managers, home-delivered meal drivers, and food purveyors. SUAs,
AAAs, and local providers should rely on professionals, preferably registered
dietitians or nutritionists, to assist in the development, implementation,
and approval of menus for OANPs. (Chapter 2 provides a description of
a registered dietitian). Ideally, the menu will reflect local food preferences,
provide variety in shape, color, temperature, texture, and flavor, consider
food availability (foods in season), and costs. Well planned menus improve
meal quality and increase client satisfaction (17).
The Issue
Panel recommended that OANPs plan and evaluate meals for meeting nutritional
requirements using computer-assisted nutrient analysis and that Registered
Dietitians (or individuals with comparable expertise) be available at
the state, area, and local provider levels to assure nutrient adequacy
of meals (16).
| Nutrient
Analysis Software |
A variety
of nutrient analysis and meal production software products are available
and used by SUAs, AAAs, and providers. Some simply provide analysis of
foods, recipes, and menus. Others offer food production, inventory, and
costing capabilities. The National Policy and Resource Center on Nutrition
and Aging surveyed SUAs (12/02) concerning their use and requirements
to use nutrient analysis software. (Click here for complete survey). Below
is a summary of some of the responses. Additional responses are included
in the "Menu Review and Approval" section of this chapter.
State Unit
on Aging Respondents (N = 33)
- 10 SUAs
use computer software to analyze the nutrient content of meals. These
include Food Processor (6 SUAs), Nutritionist Pro (2 SUAs), FoodWorks
(1), Computrition (1), and Nutritionist V (1).
- Factors
influencing the selection of Food Processor software were cost, ease
of use, ability to add to the data base, completeness of the database,
and technical support. Nutritionist Pro and Foodworks were selected
for similar reasons. Nutritionist V was selected because it provided
quantity recipes. Computrition was used by a large vendor to do forecasting,
inventory control, etc.
- 6 SUAs
recommended a particular brand of nutrient analysis software for AAA
and provider use: Food Processor (4 SUAs), NutritionistPro (1), and
Nutritionist IV or more (1). Several SUAs indicated they provide no
specific recommendations.
- SUAs identified
nutrient analysis software commonly used by AAAs and providers: Food
Processor (9 SUAs ), Nutritionist IV or V (5), Nutritionist Pro (4),
Computrition (4), and Master cook (2).
The following
list of nutrition software products was compiled by the Center:
A meal pattern
is best used as a menu-planning tool (ensuring food plate coverage, and
as a component of a catering contract) rather than as a standard for nutritional
adequacy or as a compliance tool. Use of computerized nutrient analysis
rather than a meal pattern helps ensure nutritional adequacy of meals
and increases menu planning flexibility. Many SUAs require documentation
that menus meet nutrient requirements using computer-assisted nutrient
analysis. Some SUAs specify that meals must follow a meal pattern with
no deviation.
Additional
guidance is often provided for accompaniments such as desserts, condiments
including margarine, salad dressings, and relishes, and beverages other
than milk. Specific guidance is frequently included to ensure that foods
high in key nutrients are provided. Recommendations for inclusion of foods
high in vitamins A and C and fiber are common. In addition, information
is typically provided in SUA guidelines to ensure that menus incorporate
foods that are lower in sodium, fat, saturated fat, and cholesterol.
The 1972
meal pattern (still used by many OANPs today) first appeared in the Guide
to Effective Project Operations, The Nutrition Program for the Elderly
(the Oregon Guide, 1973). It was assumed that if a variety of foods were
provided daily in the amounts indicated and proper food preparation and
handling was practiced, the meal would provide at least 1/3 of the 1968
RDAs. The pattern became the quick checklist for determining the nutritional
adequacy of a meal. Some SUAs added requirements that meals provide foods
high in specific nutrients, such as vitamins A and C, as well as some
others. This pattern does not ensure that the new DRI requirements are
met for calories, carbohydrates, magnesium, folate, vitamin E, and fiber
as noted in the Issue
Panel Report: Table 4.1 Nutrient Composition of the 1972 Meal Pattern
[page 53 of 62] (16). These variations in menu planning may be addressed
in state guidelines.
| Updated
Sample Meal Pattern to Meet New DRIs |
The updated
sample meal pattern below is based on the newer DRIs for energy as calculated
for the table above, "Dietary Reference Intakes for Meal Planning
and Evaluation." It provides approximately 685 calories per meal.
The number of servings for each food group are based on USDA's Food
Guide: Background and Development, Table 5 Nutrient profiles for food
groups and subgroup composites. These profiles represent the quantities
of nutrients and other components that one would expect to obtain on average
from a serving of food in each group (18). Information from Table 5
Nutrient profiles... and from USDA's Agricultural Research Service,
Home
and Garden Bulletin No.72 (Revised October 2002) was used to determine
the appropriate number of food group servings to best meet the new DRIs.
See table, "Nutrient
Composition of a Sample Meal Pattern."
The updated
sample meal pattern includes 1 additional serving of bread or bread alternate
and another serving of vegetable or fruit compared to the 1972 meal pattern.
Serving sizes are based on the Food Guide Pyramid. The number of
servings reflects an appropriate distribution of foods for the day, particularly
for lunch or supper. Servings from a food group may be combined as one
larger serving. For example, 2 servings from the bread or bread alternate
food group may include 2 slices of bread for a sandwich or 1 cup of pasta
or rice or it may include 1/2 cup pasta and 1 slice of bread. Likewise,
2 servings of vegetable may be 1/2 cup mashed potato and 1/2 cup green
beans or 1 cup of either vegetable. The pattern provides the option for
substituting 1 fruit serving for a vegetable serving and vice versa.
This updated
sample meal pattern, although based on the food servings recommended in
the Food Guide Pyramid, does not assure that meals meet 1/3 the
DRIs and the 2000 Dietary Guidelines. Meals are likely to require
specific types of fruits and vegetables, whole grains, and high fiber
foods. Based on the information used from USDA's Food Guide: Background
and Development, Table 5 Nutrient profiles for food groups and subgroup
composites, the updated meal pattern may be deficient in vitamin E,
requiring extra care in the selection of foods that are good sources of
this nutrient (see "Sources of Key Nutrients" section of this
chapter). Because of the increased nutrient requirements, it may be difficult
for some participants to eat the amount of food for 1 meal at 1 sitting.
The use of nutrient dense foods as well as fortified and enriched products
should be a priority. In addition, calories from carbohydrates, fats,
and/or proteins will require adjustment for underweight or overweight
individuals. As appropriate for the weight status of participants, the
provision of food supplements and modifications in serving sizes of particular
food groups may be needed.
| Food
Group |
Servings
per meal(1,2) |
Dietary
Guidelines(3)
Servings per day |
| Bread
or Bread Alternate |
2
servings (1 cup pasta or rice; 2 slices of bread (1 oz each) or equivalent
combinations) |
6-9
servings daily. Include several servings of whole grain (high fiber)
foods. |
| Vegetable |
2
serving(s): ½ cup or equivalent measure (may serve an additional
vegetable instead of a fruit) |
3-4
servings daily. Include dark-green leafy; or orange vegetables, cooked
dry peas and beans. |
| Fruit |
1
serving: ½ cup or equivalent measure (may serve an additional
fruit instead of a vegetable) |
2-3
servings daily. Include deeply colored such as orange fruits. |
| Milk
or Milk Alternate |
1
serving: 1 cup or equivalent measure |
3
servings daily, select low fat products |
| Meat
or Meat Alternate |
1
serving: 3 oz or equivalent measure |
2
servings daily, total of 6 ounces |
| Fats |
1
serving: 1 teaspoon or equivalent measure |
Select
foods lower in fat, saturated fat, and cholesterol. Limit total fat
to 30% and saturated fat 10% of calories. |
| Dessert |
Varies
(see suggested dessert options) |
Select
foods high in whole grains, low in fat and sugars |
| Sodium |
|
Select
and prepare foods with less salt or sodium |
(1) The number
of servings per meal provides for 1/3 of the DRIs as calculated in Table
"Nutrient Composition of a Suggested Meal Pattern for Older Americans
Nutrition Program Meals. This table is based on USDA's Food Guide Background
and Development, Table 5, Nutrient Profiles for Food Group and Subgroup
Composites. This meal pattern also relates to Table "Dietary Reference
Intakes for Meal Planning and Evaluation" in this chapter.
(2) Caloric
value (685 Kcal) based on a 75 year old male, height of 5'7", "
low active" physical activity level (PAL). Using Table 5-22 Estimated
Energy Requirements (EER) for Men and Women 30 Years of Age, calculated
the median BMI and calorie level for men and substracted 10 kcal/day (from
2504 kcal) for each year of age above 30.
(3) The caloric requirement in the 2000 Dietary Guidelines is 1600-2200
calories.
| Suggested
Food Group Components and Serving Size |
The food
group information below generally follows the 2000 Dietary Guidelines
and Food Guide Pyramid. Although some foods are classified in more
than 1 food group, a serving of a food can only be counted in 1 food group
within the same meal. For example, dried beans may be counted as either
a meat alternate serving or as a vegetable serving but not both in the
same meal. Likewise, cottage cheese may be counted as either meat alternate
serving or milk alternate serving but not both.
|
Compiled
from the Dietary Guidelines for Americans 2000 and Florida,
Massachusetts, and Ohio standards:
1.
Bread or Bread Alternate
- A
serving of bread is generally 1 slice (1 ounce); ½ cup
pasta or grain product; or 1 ounce of ready-to-eat cereal. Bread
and bread alternates include:
- 1
small 2 ounce muffin
- 2"
cube cornbread
- 1
biscuit, 2.5" diameter
- 1
waffle, 7" diameter
- 1
slice French toast
- 1/2
English muffin
- 1
tortilla, 6" diameter
- 2
pancakes, 4" diameter
- 1/2
bagel
- 1
small sandwich bun
- 1/2
cup cooked cereal
- 4-6
crackers
- 1/2
large sandwich bun
- 3/4
cup ready to eat cereal
- 2
graham cracker squares
- 1/2
cup bread dressing/stuffing
- 1/2
cup pasta, noodles, rice
- A
variety of enriched and/or whole grain bread products, particularly
those high in fiber, are recommended.
- Bread
alternates do not include starchy vegetables such as potatoes,
sweet potatoes, corn, yams, or plantains. These foods are included
in the vegetable food group.
2.
Vegetables
- A
serving of vegetable (including dried beans, peas and lentils)
is generally ½ cup cooked or raw vegetable; or ¾
cup 100% vegetable juice; or 1 cup raw leafy vegetable. For prepacked
100% vegetable juices, a ½ cup juice pack may be counted
as a serving if a ¾ cup pre-packed serving is not available).
- Fresh
or frozen vegetables are preferred, canned vegetables.
- Vegetables
as a primary ingredient in soups, stews, casseroles or other combination
dishes should total ½ cup per serving.
3.
Fruits
- A
serving of fruit is generally a medium apple, banana, orange,
or pear; ½ cup chopped, cooked, or canned fruit; or ¾
cup 100% fruit juice. For prepacked 100% fruit juices, a ½
cup juice pack may be counted as a serving if a ¾ cup pre-packed
serving is not available).
- Fresh,
frozen, or canned fruit will preferably be packed in juice, light
syrup or without sugar.
4.
Milk or Milk Alternates
- One
cup whole, low fat, skim, buttermilk, low-fat chocolate milk,
or lactose-free milk fortified with Vitamins A and D should be
used. Low-fat or skim milk is recommended for the general population.
Powdered dry milk (1/3 cup) or evaporated milk (½ cup)
may be served as part of a home-delivered meal. (Some states restrict
serving reconstituted powdered milk.)
- Milk
alternates for the equivalent of one cup of milk include:
- 1
cup yogurt
- 1½
cups cottage cheese
- 8
ounces tofu (processed with calcium salt)
- 1½
ounces natural or 2 ounces processed cheese
- 1½
cups ice milk/ice cream
5.
Meat or Meat Alternate
- Three
ounces of meat or meat alternate should generally be provided
for the lunch or supper meal. Meat serving weight is the edible
portion, not including skin, bone, or coating.
- 1
egg
- 1
ounce cheese (nutritionally equivalent measure of pasteurized
process cheese cheese food, cheese spread, or other cheese product)
- ½
cup cooked dried beans, peas or lentils
- 2
tablespoon peanut butter or 1/3 cup nuts
- ¼
cup cottage cheese
- ½
cup tofu
- A
one ounce serving or equivalent portion of meat, poultry, fish,
may be served in combination with other high protein foods.
- Except
to meet cultural and religious preferences and for emergency meals,
avoid serving dried beans, peas or lentils, peanut butter or peanuts,
and tofu for consecutive meals or on consecutive days.
- Imitation
cheese (which the Food and Drug Administration defines as one
not meeting nutritional equivalency requirements for the natural,
non-imitation product) cannot be served as meat alternates.
- To
limit the sodium content of the meals, serve no more than once
a week cured and processed meats (eg, ham, smoked or Polish sausage,
corned beef, wieners, luncheon meats, dried beef).
Accompaniments
Include
traditional meal accompaniments as appropriate, eg, condiments,
spreads, garnishes. Examples include: mustard and/or mayonnaise
with a meat sandwich, tartar sauce with fish, salad dressing with
tossed salad, margarine with bread or rolls. Whenever feasible,
provide reduced fat alternatives. Minimize use of fat in food preparation.
Fats should be primarily from primarily vegetable sources and in
a liquid or soft (spreadable) form that are lower in hydrogenated
fat, saturated fat, and cholesterol.
Desserts
Serving
a dessert may or may not be required by the SUA. Healthier desserts
generally include fruit, whole grains, low fat products, and/or
limited sugar. States may limit the number of times a high sugar
or high fat item is provided (eg, cakes, cookies, pies). Fresh,
frozen, or canned fruits packed in their own juice are often encouraged
as a dessert item in addition to the serving of fruit provided
as part of the meal.
Beverages
Fluid intake should be encouraged as dehydration is a common problem
in older adults. It is a good practice to have drinking water available.
Other beverages such as juices, coffee, tea, decaffeinated beverages,
soft drinks, and flavored drinks, may be served. Nonnutritive beverages
do not help meet nutrition requirements but can help with hydration.
Alcoholic beverages should not be provided with OAA funds.
|
| Enhancing
the Nutritional Quality of the Meal: Key Nutrients |
The Issue
Panel recommended that OANPs emphasize foods that are high in fiber, calcium,
and protein, and continue to target vitamins A and C, with vitamin A provided
from vegetable-derived (carotenoid) sources. Targeting specific nutrients
mentioned in this recommendation should not be misinterpreted as permission
to ignore other nutrients (16). A number of studies found specific nutrients
to be deficient in diets of older adults (8,19,20). While the National
Evaluation revealed that OANP meals supplied over 33% of the 1989
RDAs for key nutrients. When compared to the newer DRIs, meals were inadequate
in vitamins D and E, folate, calcium, and magnesium (8). The Continuing
Survey of Food Intakes by Individuals 1994-1996 found older adults'
dietary intake to be low in calories, total fat, fiber, carbohydrate,
vitamin E, folate, calcium, and magnesium (19). The Third National
Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES III) found older adults'
dietary intake to be low in calories, total fat, fiber, calcium, magnesium,
zinc, copper, folate, and vitamins B6, C and E (20). Therefore, the following
require special attention: vitamins A, B-6, C, D, E, and folate; calcium,
copper, magnesium, zinc; and calories, carbohydrates, total fat, protein,
and fiber. More
definitive guidance concerning targeting key nutrients will be developed
as part of the next Issue Panel on the implementation of the DRIs.
Foods considered
good sources of specific nutrients are shown in the following table prepared
by the Center. Information provides "good" and "high"
food sources of specific nutrients. A "high source" is defined
as providing 20% or more of the Daily Value for a given nutrient per serving.
A "good source" is federally defined as providing 10-19% of
the Daily Value for a given nutrient per serving. See summary of the use
and meaning of Daily Values that follows the table. Foods selected for
the table meet the above parameters using typical serving sizes.
The USDA's
National
Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 15 Nutrient List
was used to develop the table (21). The database contains reports of selected
food items and nutrients sorted by food description or in descending order
by nutrient content in terms of common household measures. The food items
and weights are adapted from Home and Garden Bulletin No. 72, Nutritive
Value of Foods.
|
Nutrient
|
Food
|
Serving
Size
|
Amt
|
%
DV c
|
|
Calcium
|
-
|
-
|
mg
|
-
|
|
High
|
Yogurt,
plain, lowfat
|
8
oz
|
345
|
35
|
|
-
|
Milk
1% w/ added Vit A
|
1
cup
|
300
|
25
|
|
Good
|
Cheddar
cheese
|
1
oz
|
204
|
17
|
|
-
|
Collard
greens, cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
179
|
15
|
|
-
|
Turnip
greens, cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
125
|
10
|
|
-
|
Spinach,
cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
123
|
10
|
|
Magnesium
|
-
|
-
|
mg
|
-
|
|
High
|
Finfish,
Halibut
|
1/2
fillet
|
170
|
40
|
|
Good
|
Spinach,
cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
79
|
19
|
|
-
|
Soybean,
cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
74
|
18
|
|
-
|
Beans,
white, canned
|
1/2
cup
|
67
|
16
|
|
-
|
Beans,
black, cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
60
|
14
|
|
-
|
Artichokes,
Cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
51
|
12
|
|
-
|
Beet
greens, cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
49
|
12
|
|
-
|
Lima
beans, cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
47
|
11
|
|
-
|
Okra,
frozen, cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
47
|
11
|
|
-
|
Oat
bran, cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
44
|
10
|
|
-
|
Brown
rice, cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
42
|
10
|
|
Vitamin
B12
|
-
|
-
|
mg
|
-
|
|
High
|
Yogurt,
plain. lowfat
|
8
oz
|
0.49
|
37
|
|
-
|
Milk
1%, w/ added vit A
|
1
cup
|
0.41
|
31
|
|
-
|
Egg
whole, scrambled/hard-boiled
|
1
Lg
|
0.27
|
21
|
|
Good
|
Soybeans,
cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
0.25
|
19
|
|
-
|
Ricotta
cheese, whole milk
|
1/2
cup
|
0.24
|
18
|
|
-
|
Mushrooms,
cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
0.23
|
18
|
|
-
|
Spinach,
cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
0.21
|
16
|
|
-
|
Beet
greens, cooked
|
1/2
cup
|
0.21
|
16
|
|
-
|
Cottage
cheese, lowfat
|
1/2
cup
|
0.19 | |